This tubing mascara encases lashes with a shiny black film that elongates and doesn’t smudge. It’s not technically waterproof, but it’s exceptionally durable and long-lasting.]
Washable mascaras often break down throughout the day, flaking into the eye and causing irritation, especially for those with sensitive eyes. Tenacious waterproof formulas might fare a bit better, but getting them off could require irritating remover and rubbing. Tubing mascaras are known for creating dramatic, lush lashes, but they also happen to be far less irritating to eyes.
Androulakis said, “Their higher level of film formers give the strongest performance and wear.” They envelop and seal each lash in a flake-free sheath until removed, sliding off each lash in “tubes” with just warm water and a gentle pulling motion.
While testing, we discovered that removing these formulas, such as that of our pick from Thrive Causemetics, does have a bit of a learning curve—but once our testers nailed it, they found them easier to wash off than traditional formulas. The mascara gently peels completely away from the lashes, leaving no product residue to aggravate sensitive eyes.
If you have sensitive eyes and would rather skip the tubing mascara, do avoid formulas with allergens like diazolidinyl urea and formalin (both used as preservatives), which can irritate the eyelids and cause dryness and itching.
